RE: SPS Governance Proposal - Adjust Brawl Rewards
You are viewing a single comment's thread:
The problem I see right now is with the Fray system, not with the rewards. One guild cannot decide to be new player friendly and have 20 low level players since there is not enough low level frays do be able to do that.
On the same issue, if I decide to level up my guild to make it go higher in ranks (which is what is suggested in this proposal), I'm losing even more low level frays. So no I'm not interested in being forced to fill my guild with only elitist players and be forced to kick all the new players I have that I was trying to help get involved with the brawl system at the first place.
Once they fix that issue with the fray system, we can then talk about other issues but this proposal seems to have been created by the top elite guilds out there to benefit the top elite guild out there without considering the fact that this will have a bad effect on smaller guilds.
Also, I'm sorry but because 20 people discuss about these topics in the DAO chat don't mean it worth investing 100$ DEC in putting up every of you and your friends idea that you consider are interesting...getting a bit tired of all these half-ass proposals that we get for the past month that could have need months of discussion and making sure everyone is on the same page on before wasting the DAO money to propose them to people that were not even part of the originals discussion to get started with. I'm voting no simply because this is not the time for new proposal right now and that most of them are useless and a waste of time and money.
We need to stop creating band-aid fixes on issues that actually require the entire thing to be redone or upgraded. Right now it's like we're re-applying some stickers on a rusted car with holes everywhere that we know we are going to change soon anyways...
First of all, the proposal was not only discussed in the Discord, but there was also a Hive post about it:
https://hive.blog/splinterlands/@schachoberhessen/splinterlands-dao-proposal-remove-the-reward-reducting-for-brawl-tiers-with-less-than-10-guilds-participating-and-remove-the
This proposal was only created a few days after it was paid out.
On the other hand, Splinterlands has just made a change to the Fray composition and Frays have also been lowered and restrictions that made it more difficult to find players have been lifted, for example there is no Fray for alpha cards and no for Alpha and Beta cards more, but at least Alpha+Beta+Untamed cards can be used. This in itself is a big concession to the smaller guilds, which often had problems with the staffing of the Alpha or Alpha+Beta Frays .
Regarding your criticism that this was decided too quickly, I can only say that it has now been over a month since the actual thread was created in Discord, and I don't think it will lead to a fruitful discussion if the post months, because this tends to result in the same arguments being repeated and repeated by the same people. Read the post about unlocking the Soulbound Rewards cards closed on November 21st, if you read all 3973 comments I'm sure you will agree with me that this is not productive. I respect your decision to vote against this proposal, it is your democratic right, let's see how the vote goes and maybe you will take part in the next proposal in the draft phase.