RE: SPS Governance Proposal - Adjust Brawl Rewards
You are viewing a single comment's thread:
first and secondly should be in different proposals.
For first i would vote yes hands down
just cuz of the second I would vote no because top 3 shouldnt have to redistribute rewards when they are doing their best and filling all frays. Theres many that place 4-10th that arent filling all their frays and that lowers the whole reward pool and they dont get punished for that. we should honor guilds that fill all frays and try their best to be at the top. Unless those guilds that dont fill in frays automatically count as losses and those losses add to the reward pool , this proposal is a thumbs down for me.
A big issue with the top 3 bonus is that brawls are matched randomly wtihin a tier. There are some guilds that obviously dont belong in a certain tier but they are getting matched with super weak guilds that are probably bottom of the tier. itd be like a gold 3 fighting a silver 3. anyways guild brawls need to start having an mmr system so we can actually match similar leveled guilds with similar levels of competitiveity. Theres non competitive guilds out there just putting empty frays and super weak level 1 lineups and they have to fight against a strong guild and then thats considered the strong guild bullying and getting more rewards come on
You have a point:
" Unless those guilds that dont fill in frays automatically count as losses and those losses add to the reward pool "
I agree with you and this is definitely planned to run in a proposal in the future, however @cryptomancer told us in the discussion thread in discord that this change need a significant amount of coding and we cannot expect that this will be quick, so this proposal consist from the things who can be changed quick and later we want bring in your point.
You can check out in discord - I put both topics in the Draft Proposal suggestion thread in splinterlands discord
yes but I dont feel like this should have been together with the current one
I have not put it together, I have submitted both separetly.
@Clayboyn was first handle it in one thread but I tould that it is not neccessary connected - you can check all and read back in discord.